We're into our second book for the high school book club that I run and I'd say it's going pretty well. We've doubled in size from last year (so much so that the tiny room with no windows that we meet in might need an upgrade) and have students ranging from juniors to freshmen. Half the time is spent just picking a book, but the half that's spent discussing shows a lot of insight into what real young adults want to read.
We just finished reading Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children. While it was not my favorite, and some of the students agreed with me, many of my students really liked it. They aren't able to completely explain why they liked it or kept reading, so sometimes I think it's just pure will-power or perseverance. But of the students who stopped reading, many of them said it was slow or nothing happened. Once they got to page 100 it really picked up and they were into it, but many didn't make it that far. Others have already started reading the second book in the series and are loving it.
That tells me that pacing is super important. We all know teenagers have short attention spans (and so do I, which is why I like YA so much), but it was so apparent while discussing this book, since they all commented on the pacing. A few had started reading the sequel and said that Hollow City was much better and a lot more stuff happened in it. I haven't read it, so I can't weigh in on it at all.
Some commented on the main character being boring, (until page 100) and that he was slightly whiny, though they understood why. Some liked the photographs in the book, while others didn't really get it. Many of them seemed excited about the movie though, and want to take a field trip when it comes out next year. We'll see if I'm able to swing that... But overall, a lot of varied comments on such a popular book. It just shows the vast range of teenagers interests and that there is someone out there for every book.
While trying to decide what book to read next, there seemed to be two camps: contemporary and fantasy/sci-fi. I think this depicts the market of YA pretty accurately, as there is always room for contemporary and fantasy. This time, contemporary edged out the fantasy readers, and we picked Me and Earl and the Dying Girl.
I'll let you know what they think during our next book club meeting.